top of page

The Harbor House (1)

Oct 10
19 min read

Updated: Oct 16


by Nate Malone


PART I



Late autumn Massachusetts night with just enough chill in the air for us to see our breaths. The glow of the moon through thin clouds above the wrought iron gate had me thankful for the little things. This place was already creeping the hell out of me. But then again, it was Halloween night. I suppose that’s what it was meant to do. A shiver crept up my spine as I tugged on the collar of my jacket. I was already regretting having tagged along.

Jack-o’-lanterns lined the fence, though there was no telling who might have put them there seeing that the house had been abandoned for longer than any of us had been alive. Each one of their eyes were lit, and the carvings of their mouths moved menacingly with the help of the candles flickering at their cores. Someone had placed a skull on the center spoke of the gate. Its hollow sockets seemed to be casting judgment upon us from above. Presumably a fake. God, I hoped it was a fake. Probably just some stupid kids up to no good––not unlike ourselves.

We took a step forward.

“C’mon, you big baby. You scared or something?” Bronx taunted with that fat, mocking tone. He was suffering from the high-school freshman phase where puberty had him somewhere between chubby and slob. “Bryan Wilcox, still chickenshit as ever,” he said to me. He had bullied his way into the group the same way he had bullied his way through sixteen years of life. But groups needed a kid with a fat face and a strong arm to get what they want. Ours was Bronx.

“I’m not scared,” I said with a forced grin, though my knees felt like Jello. And not the bold red flavor. More like peach Jello, or lime green at best. I was gonna have to do something stupid to prove it. Luckly, Kevin––the impulsive imp––beat me to it.

He ran ahead of the group and drove a heel into the statue of a gargoyle near the edge of the fence. The stone figure cracked at the base and toppled backward, landing with a wet thud in the soggy earth. Bronx laughed. He grabbed one of the jack-o’-lanterns and smashed it on the ground beside it. Idiocy encouraging idiocy.

“Morons,” Sam said. She was a little like the mother of the group. If moms were our age and kinda hot.

She picked up a rock and launched it at Kevin. Her arm was better than any of ours, embarrassing as it was to say. Kevin squealed when the rock caught him on the elbow. We laughed. His face went red, but Sam just stared at him, challenging him to say something. “Sorry” was the best he came up with.

“Are we really doing this?” Alex asked. Thank God for Alex. Not because I liked the skinny little twerp. It just helped in a situation like this to have someone so willing to play the coward. Otherwise, their attention might have been on me. A lot harder to play the tough guy in a place like this.

Anyhow, he was Sam’s brother––the only reason he was allowed to tag along. Not a bad kid, just ironic that he was part of the group. We’d busted far too many noses on dorky faces like his to have one of them hanging with us. But family’s family, I get it.

“Shut up, Alex,” Sam said softly.

“Don’t worry, kid, it ain’t so scary,” I said stupidly. I was fifteen and Alex was eleven. It felt more like a thirty-year-old thing to say. Sam gave me a weird look. Dammit. Stupid brain. I always had a way of saying stupid things around her. I mean, it wasn’t like she was the prettiest girl in school or anything. She was alright, I guess … whatever.

That left Carter. He was super quiet. We could be stomping toads or scorching ants, and he’d just smile. He never got his hands dirty. Supposedly, his parents were a couple of pricks––always drunk or high and occasionally beating on him. I think he just liked having a group to feel like he was part of something. And I’m not gonna lie, we liked having him around because he’d smuggle us booze and cigarettes when his parents were passed out.

“Whoa,” Kevin said when we caught up to him at the gate. His face was wedged between the iron bars as he gawked at the reason we were there––the Harbor House.

Records supposedly had it built in the early 1900’s, but local lore had it much older than that. Some say that it was only rebuilt during that specific time period to cover its history––the house of the original coven, the Salem Witches.

Gotta say, for a couple of bored teenagers in the small town of Salem, it was pretty cool to consider. Throw in the fact that it was Halloween, and you had all the makings for a good scare-story. We all tried to act like we were too old to get scared over stupid things like this, but tonight was actually the first time any of us had grown the balls to attempt a break-in. Ridiculed into action is more like it. Bronx challenged Kevin. Kevin re-challenged Bronx. Sam called them a couple of girls. And here we are.

Though history told a different tale, legend had the Harbor House as being the house of the witches hanged in the late 1600s. Eighteen of them killed, though there was no telling just how many there actually were. In school, they made a point to teach us that it was all a hoax and that the women died for nothing. Some even said that it was the fungus in the bread they ate that made them all go crazy, but others never bought it … and likely never will. People want legends to grow, accurate or not. It’s what makes life so fun––the idea of it being less boring. And legends will eat anything.

As it goes, history states that Charter Street is home to the oldest cemetery in Salem. But legend says that this was where the first bodies were laid to rest––the Harbor House. That the witches were among the first to settle in Salem, and their practices wholly embraced. Sacrifices––right here––inside of there. Or the house that was there before the house that stands there now.

Others say this was where the ladies were hanged, even though our teachers made sure to tell us that the records say it happened on Gallow’s Hill or at Proctor’s Ledge. Either way, witches hanged always make for a good ghost story.

Kevin spun around and turned his flashlight toward his face. “They say that it happened right up there. The second window on the right.” He was the group enthusiast when it came to ghost stories. Ate the crap up. “That was the little girl’s bedroom. They said she had a dream about killing her parents the night that it happened. She woke up, relieved that it was just a dream, only to find the blood on her hands. She pushed aside the covers, horrified to see that it was EVERYWHERE. Blood, head to toe.”

“How would they know what she was dreaming about, dingbat?” Bronx asked.

“Because they caught her,” Kevin said. “Took her right to the slammer. They locked her in solitary confinement and threw away the key. Still in there to this very day.”

“I thought she died that night,” Alex said. “Found her with the knife in her hand beside her dead parents. She was dead as well, even though they couldn’t find a scratch on her body.”

“Dammit Alex!” Kevin cursed. All of us were shoulder to shoulder, watching Kevin intently. “You’re thinking about Patricia Wallgreen. That was the 80’s murder. I’m talking about the OG killings––1954.”

“The magic stuff,” Sam said. I caught her eyes veering toward the house.

“That’s right,” Kevin confirmed. He turned his attention back to the house and pointed at the window on the left this time. We all pressed in and wedged our faces between the bars. “Mr. Holland. A pharmacist obsessed with the occult took to practicing the dark arts on his own time. Legend has it that he was trying to contact the Salem witches. The whole reason he bought the house to begin with. Nobody knows for sure, but what we do know is what happened next.”

“Typical,” Bronx said.

Kevin glared at him. “What do you mean?”

“Murder witches get murdered and then raised from the dead to make other people murder. Dude, I’ve seen that movie a hundred times.”

“It’s what happened,” Kevin said defensively.

“Maybe,” Bronx said. “Or maybe it’s just another stupid story made up by a bunch of stupid kids like us.”

He had a point. I never really bought into the whole witch thing, or even the murders, really. It was a scary-looking house that had been abandoned longer than we’d been alive. Of course it was gonna have stories made up about it.

“Well then, how about I prove it?” Kevin asked.

Carter spoke up, “You can prove it?”

“Maybe. Only one way to find out.” Kevin pointed to the tall grass in front of the house. “Rumor has it that the grounds became a graveyard at some point. That the house sometimes buries its own. Not all the residents of the house were brutally murdered throughout the years. More than those murdered were the ones who went missing, never to be seen or heard from again. It’s said that there are headstones throughout the property with the names of those people, but the thing is, nobody ever buried them. Most weren’t even pronounced dead. The headstones just … appeared.”

“C’mon,” Bronx objected. “That’s a load of crap if I’ve ever heard one.”

“Fine,” Kevin said with raised arms. “Be my guest. Let’s find out for ourselves.”

“Not a bad idea,” I mustered, trying to sound as fearless as Bronx. I still had to make up for that stupid comment I made earlier. “Bolt cutters.”

Alex unshouldered his bookbag and pulled a small set of bolt cutters from the larger compartment. I forced myself not to look at Sam as I took the tool, but to be honest, I hoped that she was watching. Then again, I’d never tried cutting a chain before and wasn’t sure if I was even strong enough to break the links. Good grief.

“Gonna need some help with that, Bry-Bry?” Bronx mocked.

Probably. “Shut up and get out of the way,” I said, pushing Bronx aside.

“Oooo-ho-ho,” Bronx laughed. He was bouncing from side to side and rubbing his hands together––undoubtedly hoping for my failure. Kevin was wearing a smug smile as well.

I spread my legs into a sturdy stance. I opened the arms of the bolt cutters as far as they would go. My heart was beating in my ears. One chance. I pushed it forward so that a link of the chain slid into the mouth of the cutters and then said a silent prayer. One promising to curse less and to be nicer to the kids at school. Seemed like a fair trade for an extra couple pounds of muscle. I closed my eyes, breathed my breaths, then squeezed.

The chain rattled against the iron bars as the sliced ends fell limp. It clinked over the latch like a metal snake, one link at a time, as the heavier side pulled it to the ground and piled at my feet.

“Good job, Bryan!” Alex exclaimed.

Bronx looked disappointed. “I guess you’re not as weak as you look, Wilcox,” he said.

“Wish I could say the same for your ugliness,” I snapped back. Carter laughed. The deal was that I’d be nicer to the kids at school. Thirty seconds in and I’m already finding loopholes to a deal I just made with God––go figure.

Bronx was giving me the death stare.

“Ladies,” Kevin said as he squeezed past us. “Allow me.” He took a step back and kicked the latch the same way he had the gargoyle. The iron gate shrieked as it swung open on rusted hinges. The others grumbled and covered their ears.

“You stupid dingbat!” Bronx hollered. “You could’ve just opened it like a normal human being.”

Keven bowed with an extended arm. “Ladies first,” he said. Everyone looked at Sam. “I meant you, Bryan.” They all laughed. The prick. Sam rolled her eyes, but her lip curled ever so slightly. I hate it when he makes her laugh, especially at my expense.

Bronx and Kevin took off through the gate.

Sam touched my arm on her way by. “Nice job with the cutters,” she said. I could feel my cheeks turn five shades of red.

“Yeah, really good job!” Alex said, following her. Carter smiled with a few flicks of his eyebrows but then seemed lost in his own world as he scanned the property.


It felt weird, that first step onto the other side of the fence. Like I had stepped into a different world. Not that anything looked abnormal. Just a strange buzzing within my head.

Our flashlights were like lightsabers beaming through the dark. Kevin and Bronx were running through the yard laughing and even tackled each other at one point. I wanted to shush them, seeing that it was after midnight and all of us had snuck out of our houses to be here, but I didn’t want to be that guy. Especially seeing that Sam had a big smile on her face at the both of them being idiots.

I ignored them and looked at the house. It was the first time any of us had been this close. The witch thing may be a load of crap, but the place was creepy. A long sidewalk, wide as a street, made of old-timey bricks. Small patches of grass grew in the cracks between them, with statues––similar to those outside the gate––lining both sides of the walk. It might have been half the length of a football field from the gate to the steps. Oh, and the steps––they were pretty cool looking. They were almost as wide as the house at their base, with pillars on each side. They flattened out to a patio with banisters that ran its length and then continued up––wide stairs that narrowed toward the top with banisters that connected to the porch. It looked like something you’d see in the south, if TV could be trusted––real plantation vibes. Or maybe Victorian. I don’t know.

There were a number of oversized windows. They looked old, too. Nothing like what you’d see from a modern house. Balconies all along the second and third floors. Looked to be four stories total, the highest of which might have been an attic––single room window, no balcony. But there were steps on both sides of the house that led to what was probably a basement. Multiple roofs rose and fell at different angles, stacked the way a kid might his blocks. A couple of chimneys. Banisters that were white beneath the dirt and twisted vines. The body of the house was stale-yellow, as though stained by years of cigarette smoke that seeped through its walls.

Looking at it felt like looking at something your eyes weren’t meant to see. Like we were somewhere we didn’t belong. I ran to catch up to Sam. “What do you think?” I asked.

She was staring at the fourth-floor attic window. Her voice was kinda dazed. “I don’t know. It’s definitely creepy. Did you see something move up there?”

“Definitely creepy,” I agreed. I looked up at the window and then back at Sam. “Probably just a draft.”

I found myself staring at her. With Sam’s attention on the window, I didn’t have to look away as quickly as I normally would. She had that green hat on she loved to wear, pulled over her ears. The girl version of us––black jean jacket with too many buckles; combat boots and fingerless gloves. Of course, none of us wore the tight black leggings, though I’m sure any of us would have died to see Bronx in a pair. Sam had sandy-brown hair with a bit of a wave that hung toward the middle of her back. She was almost as tall as me––perfect kissing height. Slim. Boobs. Perfectly round face. It was her eyes, though. They were a lighter green than I was used to seeing in a person, and they sure as hell made you nervous whenever they were looking at you.

“I bet there’s nothing here, though,” I said.

“You think?”

I hoped. “I mean, they’re all probably just a bunch of stories to keep kids like us from breaking in.”

“Well, that didn’t work, did it?” She smiled at me. I almost looked away. “You snapped that chain in one try. I don’t even think Bronx could’ve did that.”

I could feel my cheeks blushing again. Without thinking, I locked my eyes on my feet. My mind started racing out of control. I was doing my best to conceal the stupid smile that might’ve had me giggle if I were to open my mouth.

“Where do you think they might be?” I said, desperately trying to shift the focus away from me.

“You mean the graves?” Sam asked.

“Yeah.” My cheeks were cooling off, but I kept my eyes on my feet for safe measure. “You think any of them are here?”

“I hope.” She leaned in to speak more quietly. I could smell her. “Truth is––I like being scared. It’s like an adrenaline rush. And if we find even one of the graves that we’re looking for, it means at least some of the stories are true, right?”

“Yeah, I guess.”

“Do you see anything?” Bronx hollered from the other side of the yard.

“You guys, come check this out!” It was Carter. He seemed to be enjoying himself. I never took him for the ghost hunter type.

We all spun our flashlights toward him. He held up a hand to shield his eyes. Kevin was already wading toward him through the waist-high grass.

“You find something?” Kevin asked.

“I think,” Carter said. He knelt and disappeared in the grass.

Sam grinned at me and then took off. Alex and I chased after her. Bronx followed on our tails, hollering for us to slow down. We did, eventually.

Kevin and Carter were hunched over something on the ground by the time we got there. “What is it?” Sam asked. She really was enjoying herself.

“A grave,” Carter said. We were looking over their shoulders. Alex was pressed against his sister’s back, clinging to her arm.

“Well, numbnuts, what’s it say?” Bronx asked. He had finally caught up and was panting behind us.

“Says it’s the McGregor grave,” Carter said.

“Who’s the McGregor?” Bronx asked stupidly.

“It’s nobody, moron,” I said.

He shook his fat, dumb face at me and pointed at the stone. “It’s gotta be somebody, gas-head. Otherwise, it’d say: here lies Nobody.” Alex chuckled. I grunted.

“Shut up, you guys,” Kevin said. He and Carter were kneeling in front of the gravestone. The rest of us were crouched around them, all of our faces pressed closely. Kevin wiped the dirt from the rounded chunk of stone.



WILLIAM TALLY MCGREGOR III

Dec. 30, 1948

Oct. 26, 1959

BELOVED SON TAKEN TOO SOON


“Who the hell is William McGregor?” I asked.

“Who knows?” Kevin said. “None of the murder families were McGregors. But this doesn’t add up either,” he said, pointing at the dates. “The first murder was in 1954.”

“Could’ve been the next family to move in,” Carter suggested.

Kevin shook his head. “The next killing was in ‘63 and then again in ‘68. I’ve read everything there is to know about the Harbor House, and there were no McGregors that lived here. Dead or alive.”

“Why did they even call it the Harbor House?” Bronx asked. “It’s nowhere near the harbor.”

Kevin shook his head. “You know how you like to punch people for saying stupid things?”

“Yeah.”

“It’s time to punch yourself.”

“Do you think the books got it wrong?” Carter asked.

“Took us 10 minutes to find it. Anybody who’s gonna write about this place definitely would’ve come here first, and there’s no way they miss this. Someone would’ve written about the McGregors, if in fact there actually were McGregors.”

“What are you saying?” I asked.

“I’m saying that we found one of the ones who went missing,” Kevin said, a little too dramatically. “Remember? Sometimes the house buries its own.”

I could see that Alex was unnerved. He spoke up. “What is that supposed to mean?”

“It says, ‘taken too soon’. Maybe the house actually takes some of the people that come in here. It’s the only thing that makes sense.” Kevin said.

“That makes sense to you?” I asked.

“Yeah,” Bronx chimed in with a smirk. “1948 to 1959. He was eleven years old. Isn’t that the same age as you, Alex?”

Alex was shaking. “Knock it off,” Sam warned. She didn’t like it when they picked on her brother. And clearly, he was buying into Kevin’s crap.

“I don’t wanna be here anymore,” Alex said. He stammered back and let out a shriek when he bumped into me. Bronx laughed. Even Carter smiled. I did my best to calm him.

“He’s just screwing with you. You’re fine. Right, Sam? Sam?”

“Huh?”

“What are you staring at?” I asked as I moved next to her.

“The window,” she said quietly. Her eyes were fixed on the attic window again. The one just above the one Kevin said was the girl’s room from the 50s murder. “Something moved.”

Dammit. My heartbeat was getting louder. I hate scary stuff. “Probably the curtain,” I tried again. She shook her head. I looked back and forth from her to the window. The color was drained from her face. Almost looked as white as Alex on a normal day. I glanced at him. He was almost in tears, the poor guy.

“Would you guys knock it off and get serious?” Kevin said, annoyed by Bronx and Alex. He stood up and dusted his knees. “If we found one grave, it means there’s gotta be more. Spread out.”

“C’mon,” I said, nudging Sam with my shoulder. It seemed to break the spell. She shook her head and smiled. “Let’s have a look around back.”

“Around back? Are you crazy?” Alex said.

“Maybe,” I said with a forced smile. Really, I was just doing that stupid guy thing in hopes that Sam might think I was tough.

“Can we please go, Sam? I just wanna go home,” Alex pleaded.

“A little while longer,” she said. “This stuff’s kinda cool. You’ll be okay.”

“You can’t go without taking a peek inside,” Kevin said from behind. He wedged his way between us and threw his arms around our shoulders. “It’s the whole reason we came. The fun has only just begun.”

“Alex isn’t gonna make it much longer,” Sam said.

“I’m not going in there,” Alex confirmed. He trailed us by half a step, hanging onto his flashlight for dear life, snapping it nervously in every direction.

“C’mon. It’s not that scary,” Kevin tried. “It’s just an old house. And they’re just scare stories. None of it’s real.”

I was staring at Sam, hoping––just as hard as Kevin was trying––that she’d stay.

“Fine,” she finally said. “In and out. Just a peek.”

“Yes!” Kevin said with a huge smile and then took off ahead of us, toward Bronx and Carter’s panning lights. “Hey guys, find anything?”

“Good,” I said with a smile.

“What?” Sam asked.

Crap. Awkward. “That you and Alex are staying. More eyes for searching.”

“Do you really think he was taken?” Alex asked.

Sam and I both glanced back. “Who?” I asked, distracted by his sister.

“William Tally McGregor.”

“He probably wasn’t even real.”

Sam gave me some support. “C’mon, kid,” she said. She was like a different person when it came to her brother. Soft around the edges. “It doesn’t even sound like a real name. I’d bet anything it’s a fake. Just some stone with a name carved into it for the sake of the story. I bet we’ll find more of them throughout the yard.”

“You think so?” he asked. Her explanation seemed to soothe him.

“William Tally McGregor sounds like a pirate,” I said.

Alex laughed. “It does.”

I gave him a wink and immediately regretted it. This is not how you win the girl. “Bronx is being a prick and just trying to scare you.”

“Well, it’s working,” Alex said, latching onto his sister again.

“Found something!” Bronx hollered from the other side of the yard. All flashlights converged on him.

We hurried through the tall grass and then jogged across the sidewalk. The three of them were already hunched over the next gravestone by the time we got there.

“No good,” Kevin said. “Another dud.”

“What do you mean, what’s it say?” I asked.

“Annabelle Marie Miller––1973. Another date and name that doesn’t match,” Kevin said. He looked disappointed.

“Did the house take this kid as well?” Carter asked with a bit of mockery in his voice. Kevin huffed.

“Is it starting to freak anyone out that this one was only fourteen years old?” Bronx asked.

“You scared?” I couldn’t help myself.

“No!” he said defensively. “It’s just weird.”

“TWO kids?” Alex asked. Those big glasses of his made him look even more fragile than he probably was. Didn’t help that he got spooked by his own shadow.

“Can we stop looking for graves already?” I suggested. “None of these people match up. Let’s just go inside and check it out.”

Carter perked up. “I’m in.”

“Me too,” Bronx said. “It’s getting cold out here, anyway.”

Kevin hopped up. “One more,” he begged. “Let’s just find one more! Holland’s gotta be here somewhere!”

“Who’s Holland?” Bronx asked.

“THE GUY FROM THE STORY I WAS TELLING YOU ABOUT WHEN WE GOT HERE,” Kevin shouted.

Bronx laughed and held up his hands. “Geez, calm down.”

“Just say you found him,” I said. “Or maybe we’ll find something of his inside.”

“But it’s not the same. They wrote all these books about him. If he’s here, he’s real.”

“We’ll check again when we come back out. If he’s dead, he’s not going anywhere,” Carter suggested.

Kevin mulled it over, then nodded. “That works.”

“You guys,” Sam said. “I gotta take him home.” All of our flashlights spun toward her. “Would you get those off me, jackasses!” she hollered from behind a shielding hand.

“Sorry.”

“Sorry.”

“My bad.”

“Sorry.”

Alex’s head was cradled in her chest. “Is he crying?” Bronx asked.

“Say another word, and I’ll break your fat face,” Sam fired back. Bronx lowered his head.

“Hey, bud,” I said, putting my hand on his elbow. “It’s okay. We’re all a little scared. That’s the fun of it. It’s all just a big hoax. Nobody actually died in this house––”

“Actually––” Kevin said.

Sam punched him in the arm.

I continued. “They’re just made-up stories that people created to scare kids like us.” I gave Kevin a stern look.

“Yeah, man,” Kevin conceded. “I was just messing with you. Nobody’s dead. It’s all for fun.”

“Well, technically, a lot of people are dead if you think about everyone in the world.”

“Shut up, BRONX,” all of us said in unison.

“You’re lying,” Alex whimpered. His voice sounded muffled against Sam’s chest. “You’re just saying that to get me to stay. If nobody’s dead, then why are there tombstones?”

Carter bobbed his head as if to say, good one. I was gonna try suggesting they weren’t real again, but Kevin reached into his mind’s bag of creative bullshit and beat me to it. “You can bury anyone anywhere. There’s no rule saying it has to be in an actual cemetery. These could be from any time or anywhere. I bet they’re not even real graves. Guarantee you someone made these headstones to mess with people. Not even a real grave or a body down there,” he said with a stomp.

“See? I said the same thing,” Sam said.

He was good. Had me now wondering myself. “Nothing to be scared about,” I said.

“Then why are we even here if all of it is fake?” Alex asked.

“Bragging rights,” Bronx chimed in with a big smile. He looked proud of himself.

“Who in school has actually ever been inside?” Kevin said. “Some claim that they hopped the fence, but nobody’s ever been inside. We would be the first. Can you imagine what all of your friends would say?”

“Like he has any friends,” Bronx whispered. Kevin elbowed him in the gut.

“I have friends,” Alex said.

“And what do you think they’re gonna say when you show up to school Monday, bragging about being in there?” he said. “You’ll be the most popular kid in 6th grade. Then EVERYONE will wanna be your friend.”

Alex finally raised his head from his sister’s chest. His glasses were fogged and crooked. “Really?” he asked.

I gave his elbow a little squeeze. “Of course,” I said. Sam smiled.

Alex looked at us, one to the next. He lifted the sleeve of his oversized army jacket and wiped the snot from his face, then adjusted his glasses. “Okay. I guess we can go.”

Everyone smiled.

“Then, it’s settled,” Kevin said. He lifted his flashlight toward the front door of the house. “We’re going in.”


 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All

Comments


bottom of page